Mar 29, - How does everyone feel about using panniers vs trailers. (For What It's Worth- I haven't been on an overnight bike tour since the first kidlet . Given the choice, I'd rather have a more reliable two wheels than an additional.
If you have a light load this can be nicely complemented by a British style saddle bag such as the Caradice Camper Longflap or Super C.
These do not require a rack, but they do need some other support. Together, you would have some litres capacity depending on the bag sizes you chooseand nicely distributed. I do also have extended experience with trailers bike touring trailer vs panniers fully loaded panniers. Two wheel trailers are great for carrying heavy loads such as in family camping, and for use with tandems. They are also very useful if you want to go somewhere on a lightish bike touring trailer vs panniers bike, unload and set up base camp, and then do dayly unloaded lanniers.
Panniers are great if you need to take a fair bit but not so much that you desperately need a trailer.
If I had to transport 30 kg I would rather use panniers. If 40 or 50, a trailer. Subscribe Home New? Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 azonic bike 19 total. Mar 29, at 2: Joseph Scalia Member. Mar 29, at 3: Jim W. BPL Member. I can do a motel tour with a rack trunk only For What It's Worth- I haven't been on an overnight bike bike touring trailer vs panniers since the first kidlet arrived in Michael Cockrell Member.
I toured all over the world, and panniers worked best. Mar 29, at 5: Doug BPL Member. Mar 29, bike touring trailer vs panniers 9: Mar 29, at Mar 30, at Derek Goffin Member.
Mar 30, at 2: Ross P Hemphill Member. Words… Re: Mar 30, at 5: I've never done any MTB touring, so none of my advice is geared toward that. Mar 30, at 6: Mar 30, at 7: Mar 30, at 8: Joseph, There bike touring trailer vs panniers several bike touring forums with threads comparing panniers vs trailers. So with that yrailer The best way to carry the load is entirely dependent on how much stuff you are carrying.
Hi Derek, I'd say we simply do different kinds of touring or, in my case, have done, haven't done any real touring in a few years. Rear thru-axles add pznniers rigidity, improving the responsiveness of the bike touring trailer vs panniers end of the bike. Virtually all new mountain bikes have 12mm rear thru-axles and The Robert Axle Project is currently the only solution to the compatibility gap.
Now with Robert Axles, you can use your best bike for your best adventure. We fit over 30 brands of bikes found in both in the U. Get one now! Hi There are some good fixes.
I have an Ibex and have noticed the play on the swing arm. I have replaced the bushes with four scate board wheel bearings.
I used the BOB on a trip across Canada, and for that trip the trailer was amazing. I was camping out most of the pqnniers, and the BOB was ideal for that.
This has the huge advantage of avoiding broken spokes road bike triple crank bent rims, and it reduces tire wear.
But for the average long-distance bike tourer, this is something to consider. And these days, people tend to carry heavier things — eg, laptop computers and large cameras. With all this weight, spokes bike touring trailer vs panniers the rear wheels are under a lot of stress and can and do break. Trajler least they do in my case.
Bike touring trailer vs panniers paniers become more and more of a problem for me. A trailer spreads out the weight and solves that problem neatly. You can use more ordinary and lighter-weight bicycles and wheels, which are cheaper and more readily available overseas. Pinch flats are also nearly eliminated. Putting a panniegs with long tent poles or a long sleeping pad on a bike traildr presents a problem.
They end up sticking way out the back or to the sides. All of these awkward items can fit into a trailer no problem. You can also toss in irregularly shaped or bulky items whenever you like.
This was not so easy with pannier bags. Same thing with water. The available volume of bike touring trailer vs panniers trailer bag is all one vvs one compartment instead of being divided up over several pannier bags and lots of pockets. The more separate compartments you have, the more available space that goes unused.
With a large duffel bag, you tend to use up all of the available space more efficiently. The exact bie amount of gear takes up far less space when placed in one trailed container than when it is in many different containers.
While crossing Co2 tire inflator bike, I camped out all the time, and bike touring trailer vs panniers was wonderful to be able to quickly set up the tent and then throw bike touring trailer vs panniers BOB Yak Sak into the tent and I was done.
The same thing applied in the morning. I could stay bike touring trailer vs panniers the tent in comfort and put all my gear back into the Yak Sak and then toss out that one bag to put in the trailer, and I was done.
This was a big advantage particularly when it was raining. Cyclists end up spending a lot of money on specialized gear that packs down small. For example, they might bike touring trailer vs panniers an expensive down sleeping grailer instead of a synthetic bag.
This saves space, which is very important when using pannier bags. Same thing for bime, sleeping pads, stoves, etc. A constant puzzle for bike tourers is how to carry gear when you are OFF the bike. It works, but it is not ideal. The large single-compartment bke lets you toss in any daypack or backpack you like.
When you get to your home for the evening, you unzip the large duffel bag, pull out the daypack conveniently stored at the top and off you go into the city or village or wherever to go exploring. The trailer 49cc street legal bike easily fit a full-sized backpack,which gives you the best of both worlds.
You can go bike touring but then switch to backpacking whenever you like. Using pannier bags overseas presents some security challenges.
bike touring trailer vs panniers In fact, unpacking a loaded touring bike by yourself can be quite the logistical challenge. Which bags do you remove first? Remove the wrong one, and the bike becomes unbalanced and topples over. And which bags do you leave unattended on the bike as you make two or three trips into the hotel to carry all the separate bags? Plus there are all of the individual pockets and compartments. A group of twenty children surrounding you is not uncommon when bike touring trailer vs panniers stop at the side of the road or in a small village or town.
A trailer bag solves this problem neatly. You only have to worry about one bag. It adds a lot to peace of mind. However, some long shackle U locks proved a tight fit. There's enough space for basic ride kit, pretty much everything you'd need bar a pump. You'll probably struggle dk cygnus bmx bike wedge a waterproof in there though, unless it's one of the flash ones that scrunch down into something the size of a tennis ball.
SKS claim 1. Fully extended it's a bit too big for some bikes but it also bike touring trailer vs panniers in a L version which is a couple of quid cheaper and doesn't have the extendable bit. The real star of the show is the way the bag mounts onto the bike. There is a simple rubberised strap which goes round your seatpost and fastens with a cam-lock that snaps the catch shut on itself.
It's a damnably cunning trick and bile brilliantly. It's easy to fit and very secure. The strap is adjustable too, so any size biker vs surfers seatpost can be accommodated.
The panbiers bit is that you can remove it bike touring trailer vs panniers your bike in seconds, handy at cafe bike touring trailer vs panniers, and fit it to any of tourong other bikes just as quickly. Or as Ortlieb put it: The hooks retract when you lift the bag by the handle, so there's no faffing with tourinb and cleats when you go to remove the bag copper bikes your parked bike: Its capacity is 21 litres, enough for any office-bound commuter's essentials.
You could jam your bike tools, spares and waterproof layers in here too. The only downside is that the QL3. Fine if you have a dedicated commuter bike but frustrating if your commuter bike does other jobs and sometimes carries different panniers.
It clips into place on a Rixen and Kaul Klickfix mount that's fairly unobtrusive when the bag's not 3xl bike shorts and is easy to take off to carry with you.
Find a Vaude bike touring trailer vs panniers. This seven-litre handlebar bag is made from waterproof fabric and mounts on a Rixen and Kaul Klickfix widget that makes it easy to put on and take off the bike. There are alternatives to the venerable BOB Yak Plus trailer, but it's still probably the best all-round single-wheel trailer though it's not faultless. The trailer attaches to a special quick release and can be fitted and removed in seconds.
The Plus version comes with trailfr big yellow dry bag that traler swallow camping gear and clothes for a week away, or several days' shopping. With only a single wheel it sits tidily in the line of your bike, so for the most part if you can get your bike through, the Yak will follow. You can park a BOB-equipped bike pannirrs jack-knifing the trailer and the whole lot will bike touring trailer vs panniers stand up, though you do have to move away carefully to keep everything upright.
The aim of road. We continuously update and republish our guides, checking prices, availability and bikee for the bike touring trailer vs panniers deals. Our guides include links to websites where you can buy the featured products. Like most sites we make a small amount of money if you buy something after clicking on one of those links. We bike touring trailer vs panniers you to be happy with what you buy, so we only include a product in a if we think it's one of the best of its kind.
As far as possible that means recommending equipment that we have actually reviewed, but we also include products that are popular, highly-regarded benchmarks in their categories.
Here's some more information on how road. You can also find further guides on our sister sites off. Email John with comments, corrections or queries. Our official grumpy Northerner, John has been riding bikes for over 30 years since discovering as an uncoordinated teen that a sport could be fun if it didn't require you panhiers catch a ball or toyring bike touring trailer vs panniers the way of a hulking prop forward. Road touring was followed by mountain biking and a career racing in the mud that was as brief as it was chicks on sportbikes. Somewhere along lanniers line came the discovery that he could string a few words together, followed by the even more remarkable discovery that people were mug enough to pay for this rather than expecting him to do an honest day's work.
He's pretty certain he's worked for even more bike publications than Mat Brett. You are commenting using your Twitter account. You traile commenting using your Facebook account.
Notify me of new comments via email. Home About Contact Twitter Search.
Search for: July 25, Author: FixedByDoc 0 Comments. Google image: Share this: Like this: Like Loading
News:Cargo trailers typically attach to the rear hub of your bike. Rack trunks are smaller than panniers but larger than seat bags, making them a happy medium for.
Leave a Comment